Alright, let’s get this straight—Manchester City losing to Real Madrid in the Champions League wasn’t some epic collapse, nor was it the disaster some are making it out to be. But, if there’s one thing that became painfully obvious, it’s that some of City’s stars need to step up or step out this summer.
City fans know Pep doesn’t do sentimentality when it comes to squad upgrades. Just ask João Cancelo, Aymeric Laporte, or Gabriel Jesus. So, who should Pep reconsider for next season? Here’s the list:
1. Kevin De Bruyne – The End of an Era?
It hurts to even suggest this, but let’s be real: KDB hasn’t been the same force this season. Injuries have taken their toll, and while he still has world-class moments, City may have missed their chance to cash in last summer. If the Saudi clubs come knocking again, should City listen?
2. Mateo Kovacic – The Sidekick, Not the Main Man
Kovacic is a very good player—when surrounded by world-class teammates. The problem? City needs midfield leaders, not passengers. He was brought in as a squad player but ended up playing more than expected due to Rodri’s suspension. But when City needed him most, he crumbled under pressure.
3. Matheus Nunes – The €53m Mystery
Nunes might be one of the strangest signings of the Guardiola era. He’s played at right-back (badly), left wing (randomly), and barely in his actual midfield position. Either Pep doesn’t rate him, or the system just doesn’t suit him. Either way, City spent €53m on a guy who’s been more utility man than game-changer.
4. Ilkay Gündogan – Oh Wait, He’s Already Gone!
It still doesn’t make sense that City let their most clutch midfielder walk for free while splashing cash on replacements who haven’t stepped up. If only there were a way to turn back time on this decision…
5. Nathan Aké – Great Backup, But That’s It
No hate on Aké, but he was always more of a “solid option” than a must-start defender. Injuries haven’t helped either—he’s had six separate lay-offs in the past year, missing over 30 games. With Gvardiol, Akanji, and Stones, is he still needed?
6. Bernardo Silva – The Worst Season of His City Career?
Bernardo’s contract is running out, and this has been his least influential season in a City shirt. There was a time when losing him felt unthinkable, but after this campaign? Maybe it’s time to take Barcelona’s money and run.
7. Rico Lewis – Not Quite Ready
He’s got potential, no doubt. But when Guardiola picked Akanji over him in big games, that said it all. Vinicius Jr. torched him, and in high-pressure moments, he’s looked overwhelmed. He might still have a future at City, but Pep clearly isn’t convinced yet.
8. Ederson – Is It Finally Time?
We need to talk about Ederson. Yes, he’s great with his feet, but goalkeepers are supposed to save shots, and he’s been unreliable in big moments. His errors against Madrid were costly, and this isn’t the first time. With solid alternatives available, is it time for a change?
9. Jack Grealish – Running Out of Chances
We all saw his brilliant assist against Madrid. But we also saw him limp off injured again. Even when fit, he’s fallen down the pecking order, with Pep openly saying that last season’s Grealish is “no more.” If there’s no place for him in the squad, is there a future for him at City?
10. Manuel Akanji – Struggling More Than Expected
Akanji was a bargain buy last season, but this year? Too many mistakes. He was solid in the first half against Madrid, but injuries and poor form have made him look a step slower. Could City find a better upgrade?
11. John Stones – What Happened?
Last season, Stones was revolutionary, stepping into midfield and dominating. This season? Injuries, inconsistency, and a drop in physicality. Against Madrid, he looked miles off the pace. If City wants to rebuild their defense, do they gamble on his fitness or move on?
Verdict: Pep’s Summer of Big Decisions
Manchester City are still one of the best teams in the world, but even the best need upgrades. Some of these players have served City brilliantly, but football moves fast, and Pep has never been afraid to make ruthless calls.
Which of these players should stay or go? Let’s hear it, City fans!
Author
